Crime Murders
Pool/Getty Images
ByNick VrchotickyandBrian Boone
Meeting up with internet strangers is common practice these days. Dating apps and sites, once a shameful secret of the past, have become one of the most popular ways to meet prospective partners and one-time good nights. With the COVID-19 pandemic messing up in-person encounters, it's become even more so. Many have social horror stories from meetings like these, while others have met their true loves. But before dating apps were around, there was the Craigslist personals section, and at least one alleged killer, named Philip Markoff, used it to prove that meeting strangers from the internet isn't always the best idea, and he did so in deadly fashion.
This killer's crime spree was active for a short time during 2009, and honestly, he didn't have the most prolific career where serial killers are concerned. He didn't even start out as a murderer, and he may have never thought he'd walk down that road until he'd pulled the trigger. Purportedly, Markoff was some sort of sad*stic robber in the bulk of his crimes, whichATIhints may have stemmed from a gambling problem. Though, he was believed to have enjoyed exercising his dominance over the victims he met through sex work postings, or so the prosecution in his trial argued anyway (via The Boston Globe). Markoff was off the streets within days of his supposed crimes beginning. It's a quick story, but an exciting one with disturbing details that might make you think twice before meeting up with strangers from the internet.
On a path to be a doctor
Rido/Shutterstock
Once upon a time, the Craigslist Killer known as Philip Markoff was believed to be an upstanding citizen with a bright future ahead. When he was arrested for the murder of Julissa Brisman, according to Boston University's publication BU Today, he was only 22 years old while attending the university's medical program. That's quite a feat, having finished a bachelors and entered into the rank of med students before having his insurance premium discounted at the age of 25. Beyond that, Markoff was engaged, one step away from starting the family life.
ATI says that Markoff's teachers believed him to be brilliant. As with many serial killers, many good things were said about him — the masses were in awe — but this isn't one of those pieces that asks where everything went wrong. Markoff was supposed to be on a path meant to heal the sick and wounded and to save the dying, but this medical student decided to take life rather than nurture it. He was a killer, regardless of how it may have looked from to outsiders before he was caught. And who knows what kind of slasher film monster Markoff would've become with an M.D. attached to his name if he hadn't been caught.
He thought sex workers would be easy prey
guidopiano/Shutterstock
The Craigslist Killer had an M.O. like every other alleged serial. In fact, his reportedly choice in victims was one echoed by serial killers throughout time. He purportedly murdered sex workers just like Robert Hansen did, like the "Green River Killer" did, like the infamous Jack the Ripper did. According to A&E, Philip Markoff wasn't near as prolific as the aforementioned killers, having only allegedly taken a single life before his crime spree came to an end. It may only be one murder, but he supposedly committed far more than one crime. He was known to have contacted at least three women via sex work ads on Craigslist, met up with them in fancy hotels, then reportedly shoved a gun in their faces before tying them up and robbing them.
The Suffolk district attorney in Markoff's case said he didn't choose his victims because the robberies filled his pockets (via The Boston Globe). Markoff picked sex workers because he wanted someone he could hurt and dominate, without consequences. Since illegal sex workers live on the edges of societal protections, it's not as easy for them to contact authorities for these types of issues and even harder to convince authorities to take their concerns seriously. The American Sociological Association confirmed Markoff's apparent motives by categorizing his proposed reasoning for choosing his targets as one of two reasons why killers go after sex workers. The other being sexual fantasies Markoff wasn't known to have.
Killed himself in his jail cell
Afrandee Bulan/Shutterstock
It's hard to say whether Philip Markoff was repentant for his reported crimes at the time of his death, especially since he took his own life in his jail cell in 2010, but it's easy to assume the guy had some serious untreated mental health issues. What's the final factor that pushed him toward suicide? It's hard to say, but the evidence of his questionable mental health was literally painted on the walls.
According to ABC, the reported Craigslist Killer's death came at what can be presumed as a deeply emotional time for the previously captured alleged murderer. That death day fell directly on what would've been the one-year anniversary of his wedding if his ex-fiancée hadn't ended things with Markoff while he was locked up. Markoff reportedly took it personally, as was clear with his bloody artwork on the walls of his cell, where he wrote the ex-fiancée's name before fading from this world.
This wasn't the first time the alleged Craigslist Killer had tried to kill himself after having been placed under arrest. He'd tried two other times but was stopped before he could go through with it and was placed under suicide watch. Markoff died before standing trial for Julissa Brisman's murder, potentially robbing her family of closure.
If you or someone you know is struggling with mental health, please contact the Crisis Text Line by texting HOME to 741741, call the National Alliance on Mental Illness helpline at 1-800-950-NAMI (6264), or visit the National Institute of Mental Health website.If you or anyone you know is having suicidal thoughts, please call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-TALK (8255).
Not the only Craigslist Killer
dennizn/Shutterstock
Philip Markoff may allegedly be the "Craigslist Killer," but he's definitely not the only one. According to Craigslist Killings, a blog dedicated to keeping track of the known murders to originate from the popular classifieds site and how to keep oneself safe from falling victim to this type of murder, there have been 132 Craigslist murders to date. Now, this blog's numbers could be off, but it's safe to say there are more killings originating from the site than any casual user would feel comfortable with.
As A&E points out, Michael John Anderson murdered a babysitter after luring her to meet up by pretending to be a woman looking for a sitter to watch her 5-year-old son. Similarly, Richard Beasley lured in multiple victims with an ad claiming he'd pay people to live on and keep an eye on his property. Little did the victims know the offer of money and living quarters was nothing more than a ruse to bring the bodies, along with their cash and belongings, straight to him. Then there's Jade Douglas Harris, who, according to the Press-Telegram, was sentenced to death earlier this year for killing three people after responding to a car ad on the site.
The list of Craigslist killers is too long to fit into this article, but it's safe to say that as long as the site remains active, the murders connected to it are likely to do the same. So, stay safe in the classifieds.
His fiancee once called him a 'beautiful man inside and out'
When Philip Markoff was arrested in April 2009,according to Vanity Fair, he was with Megan McAllister, a 25-year-old medical student whom Markoff was planning to marry in a lavish summer wedding (with a Vera Wang gown and a Bruce Springsteen cover band set to play the reception) outside the bride's hometown of Little Silver in coastal New Jersey. They'd met four years earlier and started dating after meeting while volunteering in the same Albany, New York, hospital.
McAllister, rightfully shocked that her future husband had been connected to a grisly murder and other alleged criminal activities, couldn't — or refused to — believe it.Two days after the arrest, McAllister emailed People with a defense of Markoff. "Philip is a beautiful man inside and out and did not commit this crime," McAllister wrote. "Unfortunately somebody else did and needs to be penalized. Philip was set up." McAllister sent a similar message to ABC's "Good Morning America. "A police officer in Boston (or many) is trying to make big bucks by selling this false story to the TV stations. What else is new?" she wrote (via RadarOnline). "Philip is an intelligent man who is just trying to live his life so if you could leave us alone we would greatly appreciate it." However, within the week, and after a jailhouse visit to Markoff, according to ABC News, McAllister called off the wedding.
What police found in Philip Markoff's apartment
Claudio Caridi/Shutterstock
It's tough for authorities to file murder charges — or for prosecutors to build a case that will make a conviction undeniable — without a preponderance of evidence linking a suspect to the crime in question. When police began investigating the death and possible homicide of Julissa Brisman, they followed the digital trail left by the email address the likely culprit used to contact Brisman, according to Vanity Fair. They traced the IP address to Highpoint Circle, a large apartment complex in Quincy, Massachusetts. Then they did some Google and Facebook hunting for a man who lived in the building who matched the figure seen in security camera footage from the hotel where the murder was committed. Then they tailed that individual, Philip Markoff, when he left his apartment.
Once he was in police custody, authorities searched Markoff's home for evidence linking him to Brisman and her death (and the other related crimes). And they certainly found what they were looking for. Among the items recovered: a large quantity of plastic ties used in the murder, four pair of women's underwear crammed into socks, which were then stashed in the box springs of a bed, burner cell phones, a computer that had been used to view Brisman's Craigslist ad, $4,500 in $100 bills, and the probable murder weapon: an XD9 semi-automatic firearm placed into a "Gray's Anatomy"medical textbook that had been hollowed out.
Was debt a motive for the Craigslist Killer?
RomanR/Shutterstock
According to Vanity Fair, financial stress or straits may have been a determining factor in Philip Markoff's violent crime spree. When Markoff was arrested while driving, he and fiancée Megan McAllister were headed to Foxwoods, a Connecticut casino, with $1,600 cash on hand. That would've been Markoff's 19th visit in under five months to the house of gambling, where he was a member of the frequent gambler points-rewards program. Shortly after the arrest, Jake Wark of the Suffolk County District Attorney's office told People that crushing debt was a motive among many which authorities would consider. "The actions he took suggest a darker motive than a purely financial one," Wark said. "His actions suggest a desire to dominate women, to control women and to visit violence upon women." While widely floated by media outlets and legal pundits, police and prosecutors ultimately rejected money woes as the reason Markoff killed.
An investigation resulted in criminal charges, which were eventually prosecuted, and for his criminal fire, Markoff was represented by a court-appointed attorney, a cheap-to-free option for those who cannot afford to hire one. At the time, Markoff owed more than $130,000 and had no present means of financial support — not a job or any kind of allowance from his family.
He had a victim's blood on him when he was arrested
Vadim Kulikov/Shutterstock
In March 2011, according to the Associated Press (via MassLive), Suffolk County District Attorney Dan Conley held a press conference to release the case file accumulated in anticipation of the prosecution of "Craigslist Killer" Philip Markoff. The accused never stood trial, because he committed suicide in prison in 2010. Reporters, and then the general public, got a glimpse into the overwhelming case the state had prepared against Markoff, showing off thousands of examples of evidence that implicated the suspect in the murder of Julissa Brisman, including photographs, video surveillance footage, documents, and Markoff's copy of medical textbook "Gray's Anatomy," hollowed out to store the murder weapon.
One piece of evidence in particular was so potentially legally damning for Markoff, had he survived to have his day in court, that it made headlines. Suffolk County officials showed off a photograph of brown leather shoes bearing blood stains. Those shoes belonged to Markoff, and they were the ones he was wearing when Brisman died in a Boston hotel — as it was her blood on those shoes. He was also sporting the footwear when he was arrested days after the murder.
